Chicago Investment Banking & ESOP Advisory

ButcherJoseph & Co. serves privately held middle market businesses across the greater Chicago area. We advise founders, families, and management teams on ownership succession, ESOP transactions, and M&A exits. If you are weighing a sale, considering an ESOP, or want to understand what your business is worth, request a Feasibility Study.

$10bn in ESOP Transactions Across 50+ Deals
$7.5bn+in ESOP Financing Raised
2011Founded
Over 200+Firm Transactions

Chicago Investment Bank Services for Middle Market Owners

Investment banking advisory for middle market companies means guiding a privately held business through one of the most consequential transactions its owners will ever face. For Chicago-area founders and family business owners, that typically means evaluating whether to sell outright, transition to an ESOP, raise growth capital, or structure a partial liquidity event that preserves the company’s independence.

We provide a full range of advisory services, including ESOP transaction structuring and execution, sell-side and buy-side M&A, capital advisory (debt and equity), business valuations and fairness opinions, all under one roof. Our firm has completed 200+ transactions, including $30bn in M&A transactions and $10bn in ESOP transactions across 50+ deals, with $7.5bn+ in ESOP financing raised. That gives Chicago owners access to experience across a wide range of deal structures and industries.

Who This Work Is For

Every owner’s situation is different, but these are the reasons Chicago-area owners most often come to us:

SEE IF AN ESOP COULD BE RIGHT FOR YOU

No obvious buyer — no family member or management team ready to step in
Partial liquidity — wanting to take some value off the table without a full exit
Key employee retention — needing to tie leadership to the company's future
Concentrated wealth — much of the owner’s wealth is tied up in the business
Owner-led culture at risk — concerned a buyer could change the company’s identity
Retirement horizon approaching — time-sensitive planning without a clear successor

How the Advisory Process Works

Every engagement begins with a feasibility conversation. We need to understand the business, the owner’s timeline, and what a successful outcome actually looks like before recommending a path.

#01

Feasibility assessment

We evaluate your company’s profile against ESOP eligibility criteria and M&A market conditions. This includes an initial valuation range, a review of your capital structure, and a candid assessment of which transaction types are realistic.

#02

Transaction structuring

We design the deal architecture: ESOP buyout, full sale, partial recapitalization, or a combination, built around your situation.

#03

Financing and capital sourcing:

For ESOP transactions, we help arrange the leveraged financing through our network of ESOP lenders. For M&A, we prepare the full marketing package and coordinate financing alongside the process.

#04

Buyer outreach and negotiation

We run a structured, confidential process. For sell-side M&A, that means targeted outreach to qualified buyers and negotiation on your behalf. For an ESOP, it means negotiating with the trustee and its advisors on your behalf.

#05

Closing

We coordinate legal, accounting, and lender workstreams through final execution, with senior advisors involved through closing.

Start With a Feasibility Study

Ownership succession is a decision most owners make once, and the structure matters as much as the price. We work with middle market owners across Chicago who want to understand the full range of options before choosing one.

Request a Feasibility Study

Key Considerations in Ownership Succession

How is my business valued for an ESOP or M&A transaction?

For both ESOP and M&A transactions, valuation is driven primarily by EBITDA and the applicable market multiple for your industry. In an ESOP, ERISA requires adequate consideration supported by an independent appraisal by a qualified valuation firm, engaged by the trustee. ESOP transactions require an independent valuation and are best served by an independent trustee. In M&A, market-tested bids from qualified buyers establish price. Our role is to prepare the business and run a process that gives buyers or the trustee a clear view of how it performs.

How are these transactions typically financed?

ESOP buyouts are usually structured with a combination of senior bank debt, seller financing, and, in some cases, mezzanine capital. The company borrows and lends the proceeds to the ESOP trust, which buys the shares, and the loan is repaid from company cash flow over time. Repurchase obligations apply to departing or retiring employee plan participants who have accumulated stock in the trust, not to selling shareholders; under federal rules and the plan’s terms, distributions can generally be deferred up to 5 plan years and paid in installments. M&A transactions may involve a mix of buyer equity, acquisition financing, and rollover equity where the seller retains a stake.

Can I sell part of the business rather than all of it?

Partial transactions are common and can be the right structure. A partial ESOP sale, for example, can give an owner meaningful liquidity while retaining an equity stake and continuing to lead the company. Partial M&A recapitalizations serve a similar purpose with a financial sponsor as the buyer. The limitations matter as much as the benefits: the owner keeps exposure to the business, any second-step liquidity depends on later performance and financing conditions, and a leveraged partial ESOP adds debt service the company must carry.

What are the tax implications of an ESOP transaction?

S-corporations are pass-through entities. In an S corporation, the ESOP trust’s share of earnings is exempt from unrelated business income tax (UBIT), and that benefit scales directly with the percentage of ownership held by the ESOP trust and is complete only at 100% ownership. For qualifying C corporation selling shareholders, Section 1042 of the Internal Revenue Code may allow capital gains tax deferral on transaction proceeds, provided the ESOP owns at least 30% of each class or total value of outstanding stock immediately after the sale and the seller reinvests in qualified replacement property (QRP) within the statutory window, which runs from 3 months before to 12 months after the sale. Tax outcomes depend on individual circumstances and should be reviewed with qualified tax counsel.

Selected ESOP Transactions

Employee ownership transactions we have advised across construction, industrial, distribution, healthcare and business services.

See All Transactions
ESOP Advisory
has been acquired by the Spec-Tech Electrical Company, Inc. Employee Stock Ownership Plan
Industrial
ESOP Advisory
has been acquired by the Western Specialty Contractors Employee Stock Ownership Plan
Construction & Engineering
ESOP Advisory
has been acquired by the Ruston Paving Employee Stock Ownership Plan
Advisor to the Buyer
Construction & Engineering
ESOP Advisory
has been acquired by the Day of Game Tickets Employee Stock Ownership Plan
Advisor to the Buyer
Consumer
ESOP Advisory
has been acquired by the Jim's Formal Wear Employee Stock Ownership Plan
Distribution

Case Study

Jim's Formal Wear (JFW)

Jim’s Formal Wear is a Trenton, IL company founded in 1964 and described as the largest independent provider of men’s formal wear services in the U.S. It was sold to its employees through a new ESOP. ButcherJoseph was the financial advisor. 

ESOP Transaction type
1964 Founded
2024 Transaction closed
“Grateful to the ButcherJoseph team for their advisory role in this transaction. Their deep expertise helped us design a structure that reflects our values and sets our people up to truly thrive as owners”
Steve Davis, CEO, Jim's Formal Wear [Sale to an ESOP]
Disclosure: This testimonial may not be representative of the experience of other clients and is no guarantee of future success.

Meet Your ESOP and M&A Advisor

As a Director at ButcherJoseph, Rick helps founder- and family-owned companies with third-party sales, management or ESOP buyouts and growth capital raises. He brings experience across construction, distribution, consumer and healthcare transactions since joining the firm as an analyst in 2015. 

Meet Rick Hennessey

FAQs — Chicago Investment Banking and ESOP Advisory

What size company is a good candidate for ESOP or M&A advisory?

Our target client is a privately held company with $20mn+ in revenue, $1mn+ in EBITDA and a stable workforce with predictable cash flows. Stable, recurring cash flow sufficient to service acquisition debt is important, as is a management team capable of operating with reduced owner involvement.

How long does a transaction typically take from first conversation to close?

Timelines vary with deal complexity, financing and how prepared the company’s financial records are. We give you a realistic timeline for your situation during the feasibility conversation.

How do I choose the right investment bank for a middle market transaction?

Look for ESOP-specific expertise if that path is relevant, demonstrated experience closing transactions at your company’s size and in your industry, and clarity about who on the team will be involved at each stage of the engagement.

Does ButcherJoseph work with businesses outside of Illinois?

Yes. We serve clients throughout the Midwest, and our advisory practice operates nationally. We have closed transactions for middle market companies across the country, and geography is rarely a limiting factor.

Is an ESOP the right exit strategy for every business owner?

An ESOP can suit owners who want liquidity, a broad-based employee benefit and continuity in how the company is run. ESOP transactions require an independent valuation and are best served by an independent trustee. They also require sufficient and stable cash flow, a competent management team, and a willingness to engage in a structured financing process. It is not the right fit for every company, which is why we begin with a feasibility assessment before recommending a path.

What happens to employees after an ESOP transaction?

In an ESOP, employees become beneficial owners of company stock through a trust, and the value of that ownership can rise or fall with the company’s performance. Management continues to run the company. Employees do not take on direct governance of daily operations through the ESOP.

Request A Feasibility Analysis

Tell us a little about the company and what you are trying to accomplish. A ButcherJoseph banker will follow up within one business day.